Renault Forums :: Independent Renault forum - View Single Post - Renaults 5 star saftey, is it really that safe?

View Single Post
post #17 of (permalink) Old 1st August 2010
S.M.A.R.T.(y) Pants
VelSatisfied's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 16,937
Nominated 11 Times in 37 Posts
Nominated TOTW/F/M Award(s): 17
Thanks: 4,549
Thanked 2,467 Times in 1,851 Posts
Re: Renaults 5 star saftey, is it really that safe?

I guess this is one of those questions which will split opinion.

To my mind, the ncap tests may not be foolproof, nor representative of all types of collision, but they give an objective basis of comparison, which is better than nothing.

Will manufacturers 'try' to engineer the cars to get a good score? Of course.

Is that a 'bad' thing? No, as a 'good' score means a 'better' performance - nothing here is mutually exclusive.

To look at a photo, without any kind of background info about speeds involved, what the collision was between, etc, is a bit meaningless, as a car hitting another car will give different results from a car hitting a tree (for example)...

Besides, stars aren't just awarded for passenger cell lack of deformation, it also involves factors such as if the pedals move, steering column snapping, and if the doors can still open, etc, etc.

A good discussion point, but I'm sure Renault aren't making inherently unsafe cars which have been rigged to pass a series of tests.


This job should never be complete - the day I think I've done it all, is the day I resign.

S.M.A.R.T. Technician
Currently in VelSatisfied's garage:
2005 FIAT Ducato 2.8JTD LWB Gran Volume, 2000 Kawasaki ZZR 1100 D7 'fullpower' in black + full GIVI & KAPPA luggage, 2007 MB R-Class 320 CDi Sport LWB uprated by Brabus to 300Bhp don't know if there's a 155mph limiter - will be fun finding out! 2004 Mercedes Vaneo 1.7 CDi Ambiente 7-seater
VelSatisfied is offline  
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome