Hi all
I have a question which google finds difficult to Anwser for me!
My megane has an intermittent clutch slip.... No obvious oil leaks leaking on to box.....
Anyway I've bought a new clutch/clutch plate and a luk CSC (concentric slave)
My car is the 6 speed 1.9 dci...
It's booked in at the gearbox centre who insist flywheel should also be done - theres no gain to them replacing it or not as the box is off and its just an extra 10 minutes..... Or so...
Now I'm having NO rattles or noise to say dmf is worn or even failing... Car is on 117,000 so is due it's first clutch! (I've had a mondeo tdci so I know the signs of dmf!)
How reliable / bullet proof / how long etc etc are they suitable for... I know for a fact I won't be replacing the dmf as I've not got the money and would rather sort clutch slip and sell it quick, and know the garage will have no gain in saying its worn or not....
Another gearbox centre who wanted to charge me £270 + vat!!!! Said its common that the flywheel drops and rubs the clutch plate.... What? That can't be possible as the flywheel is fixed to the engine and i could only imagine a catastrophic failure if that was true! So took that with a pinch of salt along with there rip off price!
Have been quoted £40 by my brother in law who can do it but will be a few hours each night and a little unsure on the hydraulic system... Or £200 inc oil and its dropped off in the morning and back by dinner time! So the £200 is more feasible as they have the correct tools for the job!
SO IS THE DMF ON THE DCIS A COMMON FAILURE?
I have a question which google finds difficult to Anwser for me!
My megane has an intermittent clutch slip.... No obvious oil leaks leaking on to box.....
Anyway I've bought a new clutch/clutch plate and a luk CSC (concentric slave)
My car is the 6 speed 1.9 dci...
It's booked in at the gearbox centre who insist flywheel should also be done - theres no gain to them replacing it or not as the box is off and its just an extra 10 minutes..... Or so...
Now I'm having NO rattles or noise to say dmf is worn or even failing... Car is on 117,000 so is due it's first clutch! (I've had a mondeo tdci so I know the signs of dmf!)
How reliable / bullet proof / how long etc etc are they suitable for... I know for a fact I won't be replacing the dmf as I've not got the money and would rather sort clutch slip and sell it quick, and know the garage will have no gain in saying its worn or not....
Another gearbox centre who wanted to charge me £270 + vat!!!! Said its common that the flywheel drops and rubs the clutch plate.... What? That can't be possible as the flywheel is fixed to the engine and i could only imagine a catastrophic failure if that was true! So took that with a pinch of salt along with there rip off price!
Have been quoted £40 by my brother in law who can do it but will be a few hours each night and a little unsure on the hydraulic system... Or £200 inc oil and its dropped off in the morning and back by dinner time! So the £200 is more feasible as they have the correct tools for the job!
SO IS THE DMF ON THE DCIS A COMMON FAILURE?